Comparison of Modern Transformer Architectures and CNN-based Models for MRI-based Age Estimation of the Knee
摘要
MRI-based age estimation offers a non-invasive approach for assessing biological maturity in forensic medicine. This study compares CNN-,transformer- and hybrid-based architectures for knee MRI age classification and bone segmentation, evaluating vision transformer, Swin transformer, DINOv2, attention U-Net, transformer U-Net, and a baseline CNN U-Net on 1,000 images for classification and 3,000 for segmentation. Pure transformer models failed to train effectively, while attention U-Net and transformer U-Net achieved good segmentation with a dice coefficient of 0.997 but poor classification with an F1-score of 0.751. These results suggest that CNN locality bias is essential for classification, whereas global attention enhances segmentation. Overall, small datasets and the absence of inductive biases limit transformer performance in knee MRI age estimation.