A 26-year-old otherwise healthy female presents to the clinic with right knee pain after a skiing accident 3 days ago. The patient landed awkwardly after attempting a jump and experienced the immediate onset of right knee pain necessitating ski patrol to bring her down the mountain. The patient reports hearing a “popping” noise when landing. Shortly after, she noticed swelling around her knee. She was still able to bear weight on her leg. Today, in clinic, the patient can ambulate with a single crutch on a slightly flexed knee without the knee buckling. On physical exam, a large effusion is present over her anterior knee. There is mild warmth and tenderness to palpation around the medial joint line. Muscle compartments in the leg are soft and pulses are 2+. Neurologic exam reveals normal motor and sensory function distal to the knee. The patient is able but hesitant to perform active and passive knee range of motion. There is increased knee laxity of 1 cm when an anterior force is applied to the tibia at 30° and 90°. There is no laxity with varus or valgus stress applied to the knee. Compression and axial rotation across the knee joint while extending it from a fully flexed position produces neither pain nor a palpable or audible snap.