Within Disneyland—a space which already appeals to fantasy and imagination—Fantasyland stands out as simultaneously familiar and exotic, a space created in the recognizable idiom of childhood fairy tales, but one in which those same fairy tales are spaces to be explored as representative of a time and place very different from our own. This chapter argues that Fantasyland reframes medieval European stories in recognizably American idioms, reflecting the influence of the American Dream narrative. Gutierrez-Dennehy argues that Disney’s Fantasyland idealizes economic success, intertwining the company’s medieval ideal with images of middle-class whiteness. Thus, by inserting the values of Middle Class America into the European Middle Ages, Disneyland creates the past in the image of the present. Gutierrez-Dennehy coins the term “affective medievalism” to argue that Disneyland’s use of rigid narrative structures in a space ostensibly meant for visitor exploration works to shut down the pluralism with which the twenty-first century has otherwise characterized the Middle Ages.