A Theory of Punitive Biases in Risk Assessment Algorithms
摘要
This chapter presents a theory of punitive bias in Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). It introduces readers to the Punitive Optimization Problem (POP) in algorithm editing, which we define as the mechanism by which public officials adjust RCA scoring rules to minimize dissent by the officers charged with carrying out the immigration and detention policies. As officers dissent with “low-risk” more frequently than with “high-risk,” modifications to the RCA scoring rules result in harsher immigration rules over time.