Since Windelband and Husserl, Beneke’s name has been inextricably linked to the label “psychologism.” Certainly, the project for the foundation of philosophy in psychology is an essential part of the Benekian program. However, this program, not to mention Beneke’s thought as a whole, is not exhausted by the reductive perspective with which it was retrospectively approached by the aforementioned authors. Both from the point of view of the history of psychology and that of the history of philosophy, Beneke still deserves nuanced consideration as an essential link between both. In the discussion that follows, special attention is paid to Beneke’s psychology, considered in the context of his general program.