Retinoblastoma outcomes in Europe: a prospective analysis of 483 patients from 40 countries
-
期刊论文
-
发表日期:
2025年12月17日
- Richard Bowman,
- Mattan Arazi,
- Nathalie Cassoux,
- Allen Foster,
- Nir Gomel,
- Noa Kapelushnik,
- David MacLeod,
- Ido Didi Fabian,
- Ido Didi Fabian,
- Elhassan Abdallah,
- Shehu U. Abdullahi,
- Rula A. Abdulqader,
- Adamou Boubacar Sahadatou,
- Dupe S. Ademola-Popoola,
- Adedayo Adio,
- Armin R. Afshar,
- Priyanka Aggarwal,
- Ada E. Aghaji,
- Alia Ahmad,
- Marliyanti N. R. Akib,
- Lamis Al Harby,
- Mouroge H. Al Ani,
- Aygun Alakbarova,
- Silvia Alarcón Portabella,
- Safaa AF Al-Badri,
- Ana Patricia A. Alcasabas,
- Saad A. Al-Dahmash,
- Amanda Alejos,
- Ernesto Alemany-Rubio,
- Amadou I. Alfa Bio,
- Yvania Alfonso Carreras,
- Christiane Al-Haddad,
- Hamoud H. Y. Al-Hussaini,
- Amany M. Ali,
- Donjeta B. Alia,
- Mazin F. Al-Jadiry,
- Usama Al-Jumaly,
- Hind M. Alkatan,
- Charlotta All-Eriksson,
- Ali ARM Al-Mafrachi,
- Argentino A. Almeida,
- Khalifa M. Alsawidi,
- Athar A. S. M. Al-Shaheen,
- Entissar H. Al-Shammary,
- Primawita O. Amiruddin,
- Romanzo Antonino,
- Nicholas J. Astbury,
- Hatice T. Atalay,
- La-ongsri Atchaneeyasakul,
- Rose Atsiaya,
- Taweevat Attaseth,
- Than H. Aung,
- Silvia Ayala,
- Baglan Baizakova,
- Julia Balaguer,
- Ruhengiz Balayeva,
- Walentyna Balwierz,
- Honorio Barranco,
- Covadonga Bascaran,
- Maja Beck Popovic,
- Raquel Benavides,
- Sarra Benmiloud,
- Nissrine Bennani Guebessi,
- Rokia C. Berete,
- Jesse L. Berry,
- Anirban Bhaduri,
- Sunil Bhat,
- Shelley J. Biddulph,
- Eva M. Biewald,
- Sharon Blum,
- Nadia Bobrova,
- Marianna Boehme,
- H. C. Boldt,
- Maria Teresa B. C. Bonanomi,
- Norbert Bornfeld,
- Gabrielle C. Bouda,
- Hédi Bouguila,
- Amaria Boumedane,
- Rachel C. Brennan,
- Bénédicte G. Brichard,
- Jassada Buaboonnam,
- Patricia Calderón-Sotelo,
- Doris A. Calle Jara,
- Jayne E. Camuglia,
- Miriam R. Cano,
- F. R. C. P. I. Michael Capra,
- Guilherme Castela,
- Luis Castillo,
- Jaume Català-Mora,
- Guillermo L. Chantada,
- Shabana Chaudhry,
- Sonal S. Chaugule,
- Argudit Chauhan,
- Bhavna Chawla,
- Violeta S. Chernodrinska,
- Faraja S. Chiwanga,
- Tsengelmaa Chuluunbat,
- Krzysztof Cieslik,
- Ruellyn L. Cockcroft,
- Codruta Comsa,
- Zelia M. Correa,
- Maria G. Correa Llano,
- Timothy W. Corson,
- Kristin E. Cowan-Lyn,
- Monika Csóka,
- Xuehao Cui,
- Isac V. Da Gama,
- Wantanee Dangboon,
- Anirban Das,
- Sima Das,
- Jacquelyn M. Davanzo,
- Alan Davidson,
- Patrick De Potter,
- Karina Q. Delgado,
- Hakan Demirci,
- Laurence Desjardins,
- Rosdali Y. Diaz Coronado,
- Helen Dimaras,
- Andrew J. Dodgshun,
- M. Phil,
- Craig Donaldson,
- Carla R. Donato Macedo,
- Monica D. Dragomir,
- Yi Du,
- Magritha Du Bruyn,
- Kemala S. Edison,
- I. Wayan Eka Sutyawan,
- Asmaa E. l. Kettani,
- Amal M. Elbahi,
- James E. Elder,
- Dina Elgalaly,
- Alaa M. Elhaddad,
- Moawia M. Ali Elhassan,
- Mahmoud M. Elzembely,
- Vera A. Essuman,
- Ted Grimbert A. Evina,
- Zehra Fadoo,
- Adriana C. Fandiño,
- Mohammad Faranoush,
- Oluyemi Fasina,
- Delia D. P. G. Fernández,
- Ana Fernández-Teijeiro,
- Allen Foster,
- Shahar Frenkel,
- Ligia D. Fu,
- Soad L. Fuentes-Alabi,
- Brenda L. Gallie,
- Moira Gandiwa,
- Juan L. Garcia,
- David García Aldana,
- Pascale Y. Gassant,
- Jennifer A. Geel,
- Fariba Ghassemi,
- Clare Gilbert,
- Ana V. Girón,
- Zelalem Gizachew,
- Marco A. Goenz,
- Aaron S. Gold,
- Maya Goldberg-Lavid,
- Glen A. Gole,
- Nir Gomel,
- Efren Gonzalez,
- Graciela Gonzalez Perez,
- Liudmira González-Rodríguez,
- Henry N. Garcia Pacheco,
- Jaime Graells,
- Liz Green,
- Pernille A. Gregersen,
- Nathalia D. A. K. Grigorovski,
- Koffi M. Guedenon,
- D. Sanjeeva Gunasekera,
- Ahmet K. Gündüz,
- Himika Gupta,
- Sanjiv Gupta,
- Theodora Hadjistilianou,
- Patrick Hamel,
- Syed A. Hamid,
- Norhafizah Hamzah,
- Eric D. Hansen,
- J. William Harbour,
- M. Elizabeth Hartnett,
- Murat Hasanreisoglu,
- Sadiq Hassan,
- Shadab Hassan,
- Stanislava Hederova,
- Jose Hernandez,
- Lorelay Marie Carcamo Hernandez,
- Laila Hessissen,
- Diriba F. Hordofa,
- Laura C. Huang,
- G. B. Hubbard,
- Marlies Hummlen,
- Kristina Husakova,
- Allawi N. Hussein Al-Janabi,
- Russo Ida,
- Vesna R. Ilic,
- Vivekaraj Jairaj,
- Irfan Jeeva,
- Helen Jenkinson,
- Xunda Ji,
- Dong Hyun Jo,
- Kenneth P. Johnson,
- William J. Johnson,
- Michael M. Jones,
- Theophile B. Amani Kabesha,
- Rolande L. Kabore,
- Swathi Kaliki,
- Abubakar Kalinaki,
- Mehmet Kantar,
- Ling-Yuh Kao,
- Tamar Kardava,
- Rejin Kebudi,
- Tomas Kepak,
- Naama Keren-Froim,
- Zohora J. Khan,
- Hussain A. Khaqan,
- Khauv Phara,
- Wajiha J. Kheir,
- Vikas Khetan,
- Alireza Khodabande,
- Zaza Khotenashvili,
- Jonathan W. Kim,
- Jeong Hun Kim,
- Hayyam Kiratli,
- Tero T. Kivelä,
- Artur Klett,
- Jess Elio Kosh Komba Palet,
- Dalia Krivaitiene,
- Mariana Kruger,
- Kittisak Kulvichit,
- Mayasari W. Kuntorini,
- Alice Kyara,
- Eva S. Lachmann,
- Carol P. S. Lam,
- Geoffrey C. Lam,
- Scott A. Larson,
- Slobodanka Latinović,
- Kelly D. Laurenti,
- Bao Han A. Le,
- Karin Lecuona,
- Amy A. Leverant,
- Cairui Li,
- Ben Limbu,
- Quah Boon Long,
- Juan P. López,
- Robert M. Lukamba,
- Livia Lumbroso,
- Sandra Luna-Fineman,
- Delfitri Lutfi,
- Lesia Lysytsia,
- George N. Magrath,
- Amita Mahajan,
- Abdul Rahim Majeed,
- Erika Maka,
- Mayuri Makan,
- Emil K. Makimbetov,
- Chatonda Manda,
- Nieves Martín Begue,
- Lauren Mason,
- John O. Mason III,
- Ibrahim O. Matende,
- Miguel Materin,
- Clarissa C. D. S. Mattosinho,
- Marchelo Matua,
- Ismail Mayet,
- Freddy B. Mbumba,
- MMed Paed,
- John D. McKenzie,
- Aurora Medina-Sanson,
- Azim Mehrvar,
- Aemero A. Mengesha,
- Vikas Menon,
- Gary John V. D. S. Mercado,
- Marilyn B. Mets,
- Edoardo Midena,
- Divyansh KC Mishra,
- Furahini G. Mndeme,
- Ahmed A. Mohamedani,
- Mona T. Mohammad,
- Annette C. Moll,
- Margarita M. Montero,
- Rosa A. Morales,
- Claude Moreira,
- Prithvi Mruthyunjaya,
- Mchikirwa S. Msina,
- Gerald Msukwa,
- Sangeeta S. Mudaliar,
- Kangwa I. Muma,
- Francis L. Munier,
- Gabriela Murgoi,
- Timothy G. Murray,
- Kareem O. Musa,
- Asma Mushtaq,
- Hamzah Mustak,
- Okwen M. Muyen,
- Gita Naidu,
- Akshay Gopinathan Nair,
- Larisa Naumenko,
- Paule Aïda Ndoye Roth,
- Yetty M. Nency,
- Vladimir Neroev,
- Hang Ngo,
- Rosa M. Nieves,
- Marina Nikitovic,
- Elizabeth D. Nkanga,
- Henry Nkumbe,
- Murtuza Nuruddin,
- Mutale Nyaywa,
- Ghislaine Obono-Obiang,
- Ngozi C. Oguego,
- Andrzej Olechowski,
- Scott C. N. Oliver,
- Peter Osei-Bonsu,
- Diego Ossandon,
- Manuel A. Paez-Escamilla,
- Halimah Pagarra,
- Sally L. Painter,
- Vivian Paintsil,
- Luisa Paiva,
- Bikramjit P. Pal,
- Mahesh Shanmugam Palanivelu,
- Ruzanna Papyan,
- Raffaele Parrozzani,
- Manoj Parulekar,
- Claudia R. Pascual Morales,
- Katherine E. Paton,
- Katarzyna Pawinska-Wasikowska,
- Jacob Pe’er,
- Armando Peña,
- Sanja Perić,
- Chau T. M. Pham,
- Remezo Philbert,
- David A. Plager,
- Pavel Pochop,
- Rodrigo A. Polania,
- Vladimir G. Polyakov,
- Manca T. Pompe,
- Jonathan J. Pons,
- Daphna Prat,
- Vireak Prom,
- Ignatius Purwanto,
- Ali O. Qadir,
- Seema Qayyum,
- Jiang Qian,
- Ardizal Rahman,
- Salman Rahman,
- Jamalia Rahmat,
- Purnima Rajkarnikar,
- Rajesh Ramanjulu,
- Aparna Ramasubramanian,
- Marco A. Ramirez-Ortiz,
- Léa Raobela,
- Riffat Rashid,
- M. Ashwin Reddy,
- Ehud Reich,
- Lorna A. Renner,
- David Reynders,
- Dahiru Ribadu,
- Mussagy M. Riheia,
- Petra Ritter-Sovinz,
- Duangnate Rojanaporn,
- Livia Romero,
- Soma R. Roy,
- Raya H. Saab,
- Svetlana Saakyan,
- Ahmed H. Sabhan,
- Mandeep S. Sagoo,
- Azza M. A. Said,
- Rohit Saiju,
- Beatriz Salas,
- Sonsoles San Román Pacheco,
- Gissela L. Sánchez F,
- Phayvanh Sayalith,
- Trish A. Scanlan,
- Amy C. Schefler,
- Judy Schoeman,
- Ahad Sedaghat,
- Stefan Seregard,
- Rachna Seth,
- Ankoor S. Shah,
- Shawkat A. Shakoor,
- Manoj K. Sharma,
- Sadik T. Sherief,
- Nandan G. Shetye,
- Carol L. Shields,
- Sorath Noorani Siddiqui,
- Sidi Sidi Cheikh,
- Sónia Silva,
- Arun D. Singh,
- Niharika Singh,
- Usha Singh,
- Penny Singha,
- Rita S. Sitorus,
- Alison H. Skalet,
- Hendrian D. Soebagjo,
- Tetyana Sorochynska,
- Grace Ssali,
- Andrew W. Stacey,
- Sandra E. Staffieri,
- Erin D. Stahl,
- Christina Stathopoulos,
- Branka Stirn Kranjc,
- David K. Stones,
- Caron Strahlendorf,
- Maria Estela Coleoni Suarez,
- Sadia Sultana,
- Xiantao Sun,
- Meryl Sundy,
- Rosanne Superstein,
- Eddy Supriyadi,
- Supawan Surukrattanaskul,
- Shigenobu Suzuki,
- Karel Svojgr,
- Fatoumata Sylla,
- Gevorg Tamamyan,
- Deborah Tan,
- Alketa Tandili,
- Fanny F. Tarrillo Leiva,
- Maryam Tashvighi,
- Bekim Tateshi,
- Edi S. Tehuteru,
- Luiz F. Teixeira,
- Kok Hoi Teh,
- Tuyisabe Theophile,
- Helen Toledano,
- Doan L. Trang,
- Fousseyni Traoré,
- Sumalin Trichaiyaporn,
- Samuray Tuncer,
- Harba Tyau-Tyau,
- Ali B. Umar,
- Emel Unal,
- Ogul E. Uner,
- Steen F. Urbak,
- Tatiana L. Ushakova,
- Rustam H. Usmanov,
- Sandra Valeina,
- Milo van Hoefen Wijsard,
- Adisai Varadisai,
- Liliana Vasquez,
- Leon O. Vaughan,
- Nevyana V. Veleva-Krasteva,
- Nishant Verma,
- Andi A. Victor,
- Maris Viksnins,
- Edwin G. Villacís Chafla,
- Vicktoria Vishnevskia-Dai,
- Tushar Vora,
- Antonio E. Wachtel,
- Werner Wackernagel,
- Keith Waddell,
- Patricia D. Wade,
- Amina H. Wali Nigeria,
- Yi-Zhuo Wang,
- Avery Weiss,
- Matthew W. Wilson,
- Amelia D. C. Wime,
- Atchareeya Wiwatwongwana,
- Damrong Wiwatwongwana,
- Charlotte Wolley Dod,
- Phanthipha Wongwai,
- Daoman Xiang,
- Yishuang Xiao,
- Jason C. Yam,
- Huasheng Yang,
- Jenny M. Yanga,
- Muhammad A. Yaqub,
- Vera A. Yarovaya,
- Andrey A. Yarovoy,
- Huijing Ye,
- Yacoub A. Yousef,
- Putu Yuliawati,
- Arturo M. Zapata López,
- Ekhtelbenina Zein,
- Chengyue Zhang,
- Yi Zhang,
- Junyang Zhao,
- Xiaoyu Zheng,
- Katsiaryna Zhilyaeva,
- Nida Zia,
- Othman AO Ziko,
- Marcia Zondervan,
- Richard Bowman
摘要
To describe presentation, treatment and outcomes for a cohort of children presenting with retinoblastoma (Rb) throughout Europe during 2017.
MethodsA prospective analysis of 483 patients diagnosed in Europe between Jan 1, 2017, and Dec 31, 2017, then treated and followed up for 3 years.
ResultsUnilateral cases 339/483 (70%) predominated, presenting older (mean age 26 months) than the 144 (30%) bilateral cases (mean age 12 months p < 0.0005). Only 4/477 (0.8%) children had extra-ocular Rb at presentation (mean age 53 months vs 21 months for those without p = 0.002). Children from middle income countries did not present older, but were more likely (p < 0.001) to present with late-stage disease (3-4) than high-income children (74/151 (49%) vs 108/332 (33%), RR 1.25 95%CI 1.09–1.44). For unilaterals, primary treatment was intravenous chemotherapy (IVC) in 29% and intra-arterial chemotherapy (IAC) in 20%. For bilaterals, primary treatment was IVC in 113/144 (78%) and IAC in 14/144 (10%). Overall, 58% of children underwent enucleation, 36% of which as primary treatment. Risk of enucleation was determined by stage and laterality, but not economic status. Twelve (2.5%) children died from Rb. More children (OR = 146-7 13.9–1549.4, p < 0.0005) presenting with extra-ocular tumour died (3 of 4 (75%)) than with intra-ocular tumour (9/449 (2%)) More children (OR = 29.8 3.8–232.0, p < 0.0005), from middle income countries died from Rb (11/132 (8%)) than from high income countries (1/327 (0.3%)).
ConclusionEven within a wealthy continent such as Europe, economic factors may influence survival, but not global salvage rates. The majority of children still lose an eye.