<p>The genetic landscape of human infertility is complex with diverse etiologies. Identifying the underlying etiology is crucial for guiding reproductive decisions and improving management for infertile couples. Here, we aim to report on the molecular spectrum of monogenic genetic causes of reproductive failure. Over a 3-year period, we recruited all infertile couples considering assisted reproductive technologies (ART) for whom the underlying genetic cause had been identified, in either partner, using exome sequencing (ES). Clinical data of all participants along with their hormonal profiles, sonographic findings and spermograms were recorded. The study included 50 couples with primary infertility. Clinically, male factor infertility was documented in 26 patients, female factor infertility in 10, while reproductive failure was unexplained in the remaining 14 couples. All participating couples had potentially disease-causing variants in infertility genes. ES identified variants related to male infertility in 26 men, while variants in female infertility-related genes were detected in the remaining couples (<i>n</i> = 24). According to ACMG classification criteria, 78% (39/50) of couples harbored pathogenic/likely pathogenic (P/LP) variants, whereas 22% (11/50) carried variants of uncertain significance (VUS). In view of the identified genetic etiologies, the cohort was stratified into two groups based on the predicted reproductive outcome: (1) couples with significantly impaired reproductive potential, and (2) couples who can have biological children using appropriate medical interventions. However, classifications involving VUS were interpreted cautiously and considered exploratory. This study provides further evidence for the molecular heterogeneity of human infertility and highlights the usefulness of genetic testing for infertile couples pursuing ARTs.</p>