Regulating the Undefined: Addressing Systemic Risks in the Digital Services Act (with an Appendix on the AI Act)
摘要
The European Union’s Digital Services Act requires very large online platforms and search engines providers to assess and mitigate systemic risks. However, regulators and providers both face a fundamental challenge we refer to as the ‘convergence problem’—the inherent difficulty of achieving methodological and definitional agreement across diverse approaches investigating systemic risks. To address this challenge, we propose a novel dual-track framework that distinguishes between a permissive Research Standard promoting methodological diversity and a structured Compliance Standard ensuring accountability through systematic documentation. This approach enables meaningful oversight while preserving space for innovation and platform-specific adaptation, offering a model for regulating emerging technologies that balances regulatory certainty with methodological flexibility. In a self-contained Appendix, we discuss how systemic risk is approached in the recent European Union’s AI Act instead.