Watershed Health Dividend of Floodwater Spreading: Quantifying Benefits Through Counterfactual Scenarios
摘要
Assessing the causal impact of environmental interventions amid natural variability is a key challenge in watershed management. This study employs a new counterfactual analysis to evaluate the effect of the Kowsar floodwater spreading (FWS) system on the health of the Garbayegan-Fasa Watershed in Iran. Using a pressure-state-response (PSR) framework, watershed health was simulated under four distinct scenarios, including (a) a pre-implementation baseline; (b) FWS with static environmental conditions; (c) FWS with dynamic environmental changes; and (d) a counterfactual scenario without FWS under dynamic changes. The results provide strong, model-based evidence that the flood-spreading system is the primary driver of improved watershed health. The analysis shows that the FWS system alone (Scenario b) significantly increased the health index by over 100%. Even under observed climatic and hydrological pressures (Scenario c), health remained high. Notably, the counterfactual scenario (d) indicates that without the intervention, watershed health would have declined to 0.32, a 8.84% decrease. This study demonstrates that the Kowsar FWS system has significantly enhanced and protected watershed health, underscoring the vital role of nature-based solutions for sustainable management in arid regions.