<p>According to success semantics, a belief is true just in case all actions based on it are guaranteed to be successful. A compelling objection has it that the truth of a belief can never guarantee success, since there may always be an unknown impediment or a chance accident. I argue that we must distinguish the <i>completion</i> (i.e. its full and proper performance) of an action from its <i>success</i> (i.e. it achieving its goal). The proper formulation of success semantics is then that a belief is true just in case all actions engendered by the belief are successful <i>if completed</i>. I conclude that this qualification can help to construct a tenable version of the pragmatist theory of truth.</p>

错误:搜索内容不能为空,请输入英文关键词
错误:关键词超出字数限制,请精简
高级检索

Truth between impediment and success

  • Julian J. Schloeder

摘要

According to success semantics, a belief is true just in case all actions based on it are guaranteed to be successful. A compelling objection has it that the truth of a belief can never guarantee success, since there may always be an unknown impediment or a chance accident. I argue that we must distinguish the completion (i.e. its full and proper performance) of an action from its success (i.e. it achieving its goal). The proper formulation of success semantics is then that a belief is true just in case all actions engendered by the belief are successful if completed. I conclude that this qualification can help to construct a tenable version of the pragmatist theory of truth.