Legacy phosphorus mobilization by reactive silica amendments: from laboratory mechanisms to agronomic effectiveness in winter wheat
摘要
Historical manure applications on the Delmarva Peninsula created legacy soil phosphorus (P) accumulation, yet winter wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) often faces early-season P deficiency due to fixation in acidic soils. This study evaluated whether reactive silica (Si) amendments mobilize legacy P across three scales: laboratory chemical desorption, in-field pot plant uptake, and field trial yield.
MethodsA tiered approach used three legacy P soils. A 154-day incubation screened the desorption potential of silicic acid, Ca-Mg silicate slag, and switchgrass char. An in-field pot study isolated Si effects from liming effects using pH-balanced applications of silicic acid, silica gel, and slag. Finally, a field trial compared Ca-Mg silicate slag against standard lime and starter P practices.
ResultsIn the incubation, silicic acid and slag chemically mobilized P, while switchgrass char reduced water extractable P (WEP). In the pot study, reactive Si increased soil WEP by up to 70% and nearly doubled tissue Si, but did not enhance biomass or P uptake. Similarly, slag applied in-field did not alter soil P availability, though it significantly increased grain yield compared to standard management (8.25 vs. 7.58 Mg ha−1).
ConclusionWe hypothesize that pH-induced secondary Ca-P precipitation overrode Si-driven P mobilization. Furthermore, because yield improved without altering P nutrition, we hypothesize this field benefit was driven by Si-mediated stress resilience. Ultimately, while reactive silica chemically mobilizes legacy P, it cannot reliably replace starter P fertilizers. Heavy metal testing is recommended before applying slag in forage systems.