Scholarlink

<p>Business contracts, particularly sale and purchase agreements, often contain a large number of clauses and are correspondingly long and complex. In practice, it is therefore a great challenge to keep track of their legal context and to identify and avoid inconsistencies in such contracts. Against this background, we describe a method and tool called <i>ContractCheck</i> which allows for the consistency analysis of legal contracts, in particular share purchase agreements (SPAs). In order to identify the concepts that are relevant for an analysis we define an ontology for SPAs. The analysis is, then, based on an encoding of the preconditions for the execution of the clauses of an SPA, as well as on a set of proposed consistency constraints formalized using decidable fragments of first-order logic (FOL). Based on the ontology for SPAs, textual SPAs are first encoded in a structured natural language format that we refer to as “blocks”. <i>ContractCheck</i> interprets these blocks and constraints and translates them into assertions formulated in FOL. It then invokes a Satisfiability Modulo Theory (SMT) solver in order to check the executability of a considered contract, either by providing a satisfying model, or by proving the existence of conflicting clauses that prevent the contract from being executed. We illustrate the application of <i>ContractCheck</i> to concrete SPAs, including one example of an SPA of realistic size and complexity, and conclude by suggesting directions for future research.</p>

错误：搜索内容不能为空，请输入英文关键词
错误：关键词超出字数限制，请精简
高级检索

Automated consistency analysis for legal contracts

  • 期刊论文

  • 出版模式：

    开放获取

  • 发表日期：

    2025年5月13日

查看全文
  • Alan Khoja,
  • Martin Kölbl,
  • Stefan Leue,
  • Rüdiger Wilhelmi

摘要

Business contracts, particularly sale and purchase agreements, often contain a large number of clauses and are correspondingly long and complex. In practice, it is therefore a great challenge to keep track of their legal context and to identify and avoid inconsistencies in such contracts. Against this background, we describe a method and tool called ContractCheck which allows for the consistency analysis of legal contracts, in particular share purchase agreements (SPAs). In order to identify the concepts that are relevant for an analysis we define an ontology for SPAs. The analysis is, then, based on an encoding of the preconditions for the execution of the clauses of an SPA, as well as on a set of proposed consistency constraints formalized using decidable fragments of first-order logic (FOL). Based on the ontology for SPAs, textual SPAs are first encoded in a structured natural language format that we refer to as “blocks”. ContractCheck interprets these blocks and constraints and translates them into assertions formulated in FOL. It then invokes a Satisfiability Modulo Theory (SMT) solver in order to check the executability of a considered contract, either by providing a satisfying model, or by proving the existence of conflicting clauses that prevent the contract from being executed. We illustrate the application of ContractCheck to concrete SPAs, including one example of an SPA of realistic size and complexity, and conclude by suggesting directions for future research.