<p>This study proposes a Residual Conditional Variational Autoencoder model (ResCVAE-Harmonizer) that integrates batch information and clinical covariates for multi-center feature harmonization and systematically and comprehensively evaluates its harmonization performance. This study collected 806 cases from 9 different centers. After preprocessing, three types of features were extracted from PET and CT images: low-dimensional radiomic features, high-dimensional radiomic features, and deep learning features based on 3D-DenseNet-121. Each feature type was harmonized using ComBat, CovBat, and the proposed ResCVAE-Harmonizer. Both harmonized and original features were included in a comprehensive evaluation framework comprising variance homogeneity analysis, multi-center classification test, and downstream task effectiveness evaluation. The ResCVAE-Harmonizer significantly improved cross-center feature consistency. Levene’s test results showed a general reduction in − log<sub>10</sub>(<i>p</i>) values after harmonization, with more pronounced improvements observed in low- and high-dimensional radiomic features. In center classification tasks, ResCVAE-harmonized features demonstrated greater stability across four classifiers and outperformed the original features. For the downstream survival prediction task, PET deep learning features processed by ResCVAE achieved the highest C-index (0.8920, 95% CI 0.8514–0.9325), surpassing those of the original features (0.8765), ComBat (0.8909), and CovBat (0.8455). Similarly, the C-index for CT deep features improved to 0.8296 (95% CI 0.7715–0.8877). Kaplan–Meier survival stratification based on ResCVAE features showed clearer separation between high- and low-risk groups, with statistically significant log-rank test results. While slightly inferior to ComBat in linear variance consistency, ResCVAE-Harmonizer effectively eliminated both linear and nonlinear batch effects and significantly enhanced survival prediction performance, demonstrating strong research potential.</p>

错误:搜索内容不能为空,请输入英文关键词
错误:关键词超出字数限制,请精简
高级检索

Residual Conditional Variational Autoencoder for Multi-Center PET/CT Radiomic Feature Harmonization with Integrated Modeling of Batch Effects and Clinical Covariates

  • Bingzhen Wang,
  • Jinghua Liu,
  • Xiaolei Zhang,
  • Zhongxiao Wang,
  • Zhendong Cao,
  • Tiange Liu,
  • Hafiz Rashidi Harun Ramli,
  • Hazreen Haizi Harith,
  • Wan Zuha Wan Hasan,
  • Xianling Dong

摘要

This study proposes a Residual Conditional Variational Autoencoder model (ResCVAE-Harmonizer) that integrates batch information and clinical covariates for multi-center feature harmonization and systematically and comprehensively evaluates its harmonization performance. This study collected 806 cases from 9 different centers. After preprocessing, three types of features were extracted from PET and CT images: low-dimensional radiomic features, high-dimensional radiomic features, and deep learning features based on 3D-DenseNet-121. Each feature type was harmonized using ComBat, CovBat, and the proposed ResCVAE-Harmonizer. Both harmonized and original features were included in a comprehensive evaluation framework comprising variance homogeneity analysis, multi-center classification test, and downstream task effectiveness evaluation. The ResCVAE-Harmonizer significantly improved cross-center feature consistency. Levene’s test results showed a general reduction in − log10(p) values after harmonization, with more pronounced improvements observed in low- and high-dimensional radiomic features. In center classification tasks, ResCVAE-harmonized features demonstrated greater stability across four classifiers and outperformed the original features. For the downstream survival prediction task, PET deep learning features processed by ResCVAE achieved the highest C-index (0.8920, 95% CI 0.8514–0.9325), surpassing those of the original features (0.8765), ComBat (0.8909), and CovBat (0.8455). Similarly, the C-index for CT deep features improved to 0.8296 (95% CI 0.7715–0.8877). Kaplan–Meier survival stratification based on ResCVAE features showed clearer separation between high- and low-risk groups, with statistically significant log-rank test results. While slightly inferior to ComBat in linear variance consistency, ResCVAE-Harmonizer effectively eliminated both linear and nonlinear batch effects and significantly enhanced survival prediction performance, demonstrating strong research potential.