Objective To assess the correlation of pre-operative symptoms, pre-operative diagnostic imaging for cartilage loss, and intra-operative cartilage findings in patients undergoing hip arthroscopy for femoroacetabular impingement syndrome. Materials and methods Three radiologists performed retrospective independent reviews of pre-operative MRIs in 96 hips for acetabular/femoral cartilage loss utilizing a simplified “high-low” classification and the International Cartilage Repair Society grading system. Severity of supra-foveal central femoral head cartilage loss was separately noted. Pre-operative radiographs were graded using the Tonnis and Kellgren-Lawrence systems and for central joint space narrowing. Pre-operative patient symptoms were prospectively gathered utilizing the Nonarthritic Hip Score and the modified Harris Hip Score. Intra-operatively, cartilage loss was recorded using the Outerbridge system. Results A moderate-to-strong positive correlation between pre-operative radiographic and MR cartilage loss was observed (0.21 <InlineEquation ID="IEq1"> <InlineMediaObject> <ImageObject Color="BlackWhite" FileRef="256_2025_4939_Article_IEq1.gif" Format="GIF" Height="15" Rendition="HTML" Resolution="72" Type="Linedraw" Width="19" /> </InlineMediaObject> <EquationSource Format="TEX">$\le$</EquationSource> <EquationSource Format="MATHML"><math> <mo>≤</mo> </math></EquationSource> </InlineEquation> Τ <InlineEquation ID="IEq2"> <InlineMediaObject> <ImageObject Color="BlackWhite" FileRef="256_2025_4939_Article_IEq1.gif" Format="GIF" Height="15" Rendition="HTML" Resolution="72" Type="Linedraw" Width="19" /> </InlineMediaObject> <EquationSource Format="TEX">$\le$</EquationSource> <EquationSource Format="MATHML"><math> <mo>≤</mo> </math></EquationSource> </InlineEquation> 0.53, T = Kendall’s tau) for all readers/scales. Weak-to-moderate positive correlation was found between intra-operative cartilage grading and radiographic grading (0.10 <InlineEquation ID="IEq3"> <InlineMediaObject> <ImageObject Color="BlackWhite" FileRef="256_2025_4939_Article_IEq1.gif" Format="GIF" Height="15" Rendition="HTML" Resolution="72" Type="Linedraw" Width="19" /> </InlineMediaObject> <EquationSource Format="TEX">$\le$</EquationSource> <EquationSource Format="MATHML"><math> <mo>≤</mo> </math></EquationSource> </InlineEquation> Τ <InlineEquation ID="IEq4"> <InlineMediaObject> <ImageObject Color="BlackWhite" FileRef="256_2025_4939_Article_IEq1.gif" Format="GIF" Height="15" Rendition="HTML" Resolution="72" Type="Linedraw" Width="19" /> </InlineMediaObject> <EquationSource Format="TEX">$\le$</EquationSource> <EquationSource Format="MATHML"><math> <mo>≤</mo> </math></EquationSource> </InlineEquation> 0.30). Weak-to-moderate positive correlation between MRI and intra-operative cartilage grading was found for all readers/grading systems (0.17 <InlineEquation ID="IEq5"> <InlineMediaObject> <ImageObject Color="BlackWhite" FileRef="256_2025_4939_Article_IEq1.gif" Format="GIF" Height="15" Rendition="HTML" Resolution="72" Type="Linedraw" Width="19" /> </InlineMediaObject> <EquationSource Format="TEX">$\le$</EquationSource> <EquationSource Format="MATHML"><math> <mo>≤</mo> </math></EquationSource> </InlineEquation> Τ <InlineEquation ID="IEq6"> <InlineMediaObject> <ImageObject Color="BlackWhite" FileRef="256_2025_4939_Article_IEq1.gif" Format="GIF" Height="15" Rendition="HTML" Resolution="72" Type="Linedraw" Width="19" /> </InlineMediaObject> <EquationSource Format="TEX">$\le$</EquationSource> <EquationSource Format="MATHML"><math> <mo>≤</mo> </math></EquationSource> </InlineEquation> 0.43). Cartilage defects were slightly under-reported on MRI, reaching statistical significance at the femoral head. There was moderate-to-strong positive correlation between radiographic central joint narrowing and MRI central femoral head cartilage loss (0.35 <InlineEquation ID="IEq7"> <InlineMediaObject> <ImageObject Color="BlackWhite" FileRef="256_2025_4939_Article_IEq1.gif" Format="GIF" Height="15" Rendition="HTML" Resolution="72" Type="Linedraw" Width="19" /> </InlineMediaObject> <EquationSource Format="TEX">$\le$</EquationSource> <EquationSource Format="MATHML"><math> <mo>≤</mo> </math></EquationSource> </InlineEquation> Τ <InlineEquation ID="IEq8"> <InlineMediaObject> <ImageObject Color="BlackWhite" FileRef="256_2025_4939_Article_IEq1.gif" Format="GIF" Height="15" Rendition="HTML" Resolution="72" Type="Linedraw" Width="19" /> </InlineMediaObject> <EquationSource Format="TEX">$\le$</EquationSource> <EquationSource Format="MATHML"><math> <mo>≤</mo> </math></EquationSource> </InlineEquation> 0.55) for all readers. Inter-reader reliability was fair-to-moderate for radiographs, but poor for MRI. Clinical scores demonstrated very weak negative to no correlation with radiographic/MR cartilage findings and weak positive correlation with intra-operative cartilage findings. Conclusion Despite MRI underestimation of cartilage loss, the very weak-to-weak correlation of clinical symptoms with pre-operative imaging and intra-operative findings emphasizes the importance of MRI in pre-operative evaluation.

Reliability of pre-operative symptoms, radiographs, and MRI for the assessment of cartilage loss in patients with femoroacetabular impingement syndrome with intra-operative correlation

期刊论文
发表日期：

2025年5月1日

查看全文

Meghan Jardon,
Christopher Burke,
Zachary Li,
Charles Lin,
Xiaochun Li,
Judith D. Goldberg,
Thomas Youm,
Mohammad Samim

摘要

Objective

To assess the correlation of pre-operative symptoms, pre-operative diagnostic imaging for cartilage loss, and intra-operative cartilage findings in patients undergoing hip arthroscopy for femoroacetabular impingement syndrome.

Materials and methods

Three radiologists performed retrospective independent reviews of pre-operative MRIs in 96 hips for acetabular/femoral cartilage loss utilizing a simplified “high-low” classification and the International Cartilage Repair Society grading system. Severity of supra-foveal central femoral head cartilage loss was separately noted. Pre-operative radiographs were graded using the Tonnis and Kellgren-Lawrence systems and for central joint space narrowing. Pre-operative patient symptoms were prospectively gathered utilizing the Nonarthritic Hip Score and the modified Harris Hip Score. Intra-operatively, cartilage loss was recorded using the Outerbridge system.

Results

A moderate-to-strong positive correlation between pre-operative radiographic and MR cartilage loss was observed (0.21 $\le$ $\leq$ Τ $\le$ $\leq$ 0.53, T = Kendall’s tau) for all readers/scales. Weak-to-moderate positive correlation was found between intra-operative cartilage grading and radiographic grading (0.10 $\le$ $\leq$ Τ $\le$ $\leq$ 0.30). Weak-to-moderate positive correlation between MRI and intra-operative cartilage grading was found for all readers/grading systems (0.17 $\le$ $\leq$ Τ $\le$ $\leq$ 0.43). Cartilage defects were slightly under-reported on MRI, reaching statistical significance at the femoral head. There was moderate-to-strong positive correlation between radiographic central joint narrowing and MRI central femoral head cartilage loss (0.35 $\le$ $\leq$ Τ $\le$ $\leq$ 0.55) for all readers. Inter-reader reliability was fair-to-moderate for radiographs, but poor for MRI. Clinical scores demonstrated very weak negative to no correlation with radiographic/MR cartilage findings and weak positive correlation with intra-operative cartilage findings.

Conclusion

Despite MRI underestimation of cartilage loss, the very weak-to-weak correlation of clinical symptoms with pre-operative imaging and intra-operative findings emphasizes the importance of MRI in pre-operative evaluation.